I sorta considered posting all that on the first post, but I decided not to, because:
- I could easily be wrong about a lot of things,
- Dynamics can easily shift over time,
- They probably will shift merely because I mentioned my observations this time, and
- There’s an awful lot of text up there already!
I’d rather it not become TL;DR for new folks. 
I agree that it’s wonderful that many people have gained so much experience that they are ready to think in terms of optimization and how to make things even better. That will make our community richer. ![]()
I also think it’s important for there to always be space for beginners who don’t really know what they’re doing, but they want to try, and they want to learn.
Usually beginners have very little value to contribute, and if they are allowed to receive a lot of value sooner, they tend to grow to become experts who have equal (and then eventually excess) value to contribute more quickly. The quicker beginners are able to grow, the more beginners a community can take in and help to grow faster. It’s a beautiful cycle. ![]()
Because I know how beginners work, I’m not worried about people contributing suboptimal things if that’s all they have to contribute right now. They’re doing what they can, and I’m grateful for every contribution people choose to make. Whenever there are excess seeds of low value, I can move those to another context where they will be considered high value. (There’s a seed library at my local library that often runs out of seeds, for instance — I think there are many brand new gardeners visiting it who are joyful to receive any seeds.)
I am thrilled if people who have received the box multiple times are starting to think in terms of, “How can I contribute the most value for the least postage cost?” That’s fantastic! I try to do that, too. ![]()
I’m all for thinking in terms of optimization and efficiency, when you’re at a level where you can. I’m also all for beginners feeling welcome to just do whatever they can and not worry about it. (After all, a beginner might very well contribute something that they think is low value, only for it to actually be a treasure that an expert will be squealing with joy over!
)
I think a community is most resilient when everyone feels welcome to contribute in whatever ways make the most sense to them. So that’s what I try to do, and encourage other people to do, too. If we all try to fill whatever gap seems to stand out to us, usually all the needs will get filled eventually.
By the way, I’m starting to think my assessment of herbs as a category that goes slowly may have been incorrect, given how many people have now jumped in to say that they like them — so, see? I told you I can easily be wrong! ![]()