These are mainly domestic x domestic crosses. The exserted condition is in my experience, exceedingly rare amongst varieties. So if I make a exserted x inserted cross I can recover that in the F2 with a large grow out. Then stabilize in the F3. Use more broadly in the F4. If I cross again in the F1 which I just did, with less selection in the F2 last year, my overall population is drifting away from exserted with some of these new crosses now only 12.5% Big Hill and fewer years of selection in between. Only a small percentage of my 80 new crosses are with well selected material for exsertion. Crosses like Exserted Orange x Exserted Tiger and MMM F3 from the best exserted F2 x Exserted Orange.
I can reverse that trend away from exsertion by selecting for exsertion and by growing larger numbers of the exserted x exserted crosses. If I make a grex for instance, weighting it heavily with exserted x exserted.
12.5% may be enough in some cases to find rare individuals with the trait in the F2. In other instances I may need to back cross. I’ve already made a few of those and one reason for that is to make recovering everything I like, including exsertion, easier.
A safe domestic grex might be possible by using only original varieties with exsertion but that would limit my original variety choices within my collection to Big Hill, Exserted Orange, Blue Ambrosia, Golden Tressette, an exserted pimpinillifolium Andrew sent me, Exserted Tiger, Mandarin Mini, an unknown exserted potato leaf, and the best exserted of Mission Mountain Morning. Also maybe a few others within domestic. Then only using exserted populations of certain wild species.
Further all exsertion does not seem to be created equal and some comes out to play only with the right environmental cues. So some of mine has proven a little elusive in subsequent years after a year of tremendous success with Mission Mountain Sunrise in 2021 I had a year of much less success with the descendants of the best exserted individual in 2022. So I went from wondering if the cross with Big Hill HX-9 to Mission Mountain Sunrise that led to Mission Mountain Morning was necessary to thinking it was completely necessary.
I’ve also found the trait(s) involved annoyingly elusive in the promiscuous project. The One! Was originally a 2021 selection for extreme exsertion and a very open anther cone that just happened to have amazing flavor. Flavor varied in 2022 but the flower was generally dissappointing compared to the 2021 original.
An important note though. The entire garden, does not need to have exsertion. The occasional individual will lead to crosses in my experience. Selecting for natural crosses also naturally selects for occasional individuals that support that with exserted blossoms.
I have a row this year of MMM best exserted x unknown fathers and I think there must be at least two fathers so far based on some having extremely blue fruit and some very green. Most flowers are similar huge messy beef steak types. Not terrible for outcrossing potential. It would not surprise me if something like Exserted Orange was amongst those fathers. Though I haven’t seen an individual with what I would term “best exsertion” yet in that F1 mix.