Joran's Perennial Chard Project (Beta vulgaris)

𝐏𝐞𝐫𝐞𝐧𝐧𝐒𝐚π₯ π‚π‘πšπ«π 𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐣𝐞𝐜𝐭 (π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘ ):
I began this project about ten years ago.
It began with the composition and selection of the line β€˜Joran’s Naturalizable’ chard (𝑠𝑒𝑏𝑠𝑝. π‘π‘–π‘π‘™π‘Ž), which began in 2014, when I began breeding a commercial cultivar of chard with broad white petioles.
It was very carefully selected for its drought resistance and its ability to naturalize without any watering on a bare earth slope, exposed to full sun.

In 2018, I discovered chard of similar phenotype, naturalized in a former garden that had become a dense, tall meadow over the past decade.

These two populations, having managed to naturalize in extremely different environments, were mixed and formed the β€˜Joran’s Naturalizable’ population.

In 2018, I also acquired two wild chard accessions:

  • π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘  𝑠𝑒𝑏𝑠𝑝. π‘šπ‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘‘π‘–π‘šπ‘’π‘ : an accession collected in North Yorkshire, England; by Nigel Dodd, owner of the English nursery Kykeon.

  • 𝐡. π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘  𝑠𝑠𝑝.:
    Accession collected in Greece and obtained through a seed exchange.

After several years of cultivation and observation, these two accessions were very different:
The English maritime wild chard had slightly wider petioles (up to 5 mm wide) with a D-shaped cross-section. They were greenish-white with reddish-purple streaks (a color related to the presence of betalain), similar to the stems.
Some signs could suggest introgressions of chard (𝑠𝑒𝑏𝑠𝑝. π‘π‘–π‘π‘™π‘Ž) into this accession.
These plants had a short life cycle (2-3 years).
A selection process was carried out to reduce the presence of betalains. They have now disappeared from the petioles and are now found only in the stems.


Wild Greek chard is very different.
This is probably an accession of π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘  𝑠𝑒𝑏𝑠𝑝. π‘Žπ‘‘π‘Žπ‘›π‘’π‘›π‘ π‘–π‘  rather than the π‘šπ‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘‘π‘–π‘šπ‘’π‘  subspecies.
These plants have a pronounced perennial life cycle, and the foliage and stems are perfectly green (they show no traces of betalain), which is rare within the π‘šπ‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘‘π‘–π‘šπ‘’π‘  subspecies.

Its glomeruli, in particular, have a different appearance from those of the usual π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘  broadly speaking (subspecies π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘ , π‘π‘–π‘π‘™π‘Ž, or π‘šπ‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘‘π‘–π‘šπ‘’π‘ ), and are more similar to those of π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘‘π‘Ÿπ‘–π‘”π‘¦π‘›π‘Ž.

However, its affiliation with this species is invalidated due to its green flowers with yellow stamens, specific to π΅π‘’π‘‘π‘Ž π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘ , and its perfect interfertility with the latter.
But unfortunately, I haven’t found an identification key for the π‘Žπ‘‘π‘Žπ‘›π‘’π‘›π‘ π‘–π‘  subspecies to confirm this theory.

𝐡. π‘£π‘’π‘™π‘”π‘Žπ‘Ÿπ‘–π‘  are self-incompatible and anemogamous hermaphroditic plants.
So, in 2021, in the middle of a large population of β€˜Joran’s Naturalizable’, one plant from each of the wild accessions was planted.

In 2022, the two resulting F1 lines were bred separately.
Here F1 hybrids with english wild chard:



This lineage, like its wild parental lineage, exhibits an atypical distribution of betalains (red stem, but white petioles).

Here some hybrids with the Greek wild chard:





In 2023, I grew 200 plants from the population β€˜Gnarly Long Lived Beet Leaf Mix’, a strain developed by Andrew Telsing.
The plants proved susceptible to drought and disease, and 99% exhibited biennial behavior. They were not used.

I also collected two wild accessions from islands along the Atlantic coast of France (VendΓ©e Department):

  • Yeu Island
  • Noirmoutier Island

However, after cultivation, they were of little interest compared to the previous two, as they had short life cycles (2-3 years) and thin, almost cylindrical petioles with reddish-purple striations. Therefore, they were not used.

In 2024, I continued to keep these two lines separate and created two breeding populations: composed of F2s, F1s, and one individual from their wild parental line, which will serve primarily as a female for backcrossing.

These hybrids, in particular those with wild Greek chard, exhibit a perennial life cycle:

This autumn 2025, I sowed seeds from the green population (a hybrid with Greek wild chard), and I had the immense pleasure of discovering this:


These are hybrids between the two lines!
And they express a completely new type of betalain distribution!!
:star_struck:
I found 16 of them!

A perennial line with such attractive and innovative foliage??
I never dreamed of something so good!
:heart_eyes:

17 Likes

Haha! Very interesting Joran! Beautiful pictures as well. I’ll be happy to add those to my existing grex of whatever i come across on seed exchanges. Could you expand on what you mean by they exhibit perennial growth habit please!

1 Like

By perennial, I mean at least two flowering cycles, so a lifespan of 3 years.

But plants of the adanensis subspecies can live for 5 years; I’m waiting to see how long these hybrids will live, and of course, I’ll save the seeds from the longest-lived ones.

They’re still being stabilized (of their phenotype and life cycle).
I’ll start selling them in two years.

But in the meantime, I’d be happy to send you some seeds (under experimental status) as a sneak peek, Hugo! :wink:
It’s a shame that the sexuality of the chard is restrictive; if you didn’t already have a population, I would even offer you a production contract or a contribution to the selection!

1 Like

That sounds cool Joran! Thank you kindly. What are the restrictions? My permaculture project is at 200 meters from the homegarden. I’ve got two friends i could grow at. One at an isolated farm at a km and another quite far away, but he’s at the end of a small road next to a graveyard and a forest.

1 Like

Looks like I will need to breed some perennial chard that can survive zone 3-4 one day.

Found those so far Perennial Chard Seeds - Beta vulgaris - Gnarly Long Lived Beet Leaf Mi – Cicada Seeds

Are you trying to remove betalain from your population?

I didn’t mention it, but I tried this chard variety.

I have a lot of respect for Andrew Telsing’s work, but this line of chard isn’t satisfactory in terms of my objectives:
Perennial, very easy to grow, and naturalizing very easily.
This includes high resistance to disease and drought.

I tried them, using seeds acquired from the Experimental Farm Network.

They behaved like biennials.
I had to water them several times to prevent powdery mildew; they still got it.

This crop was fragile, unhealthy, and biennial.
In short, two years wasted.

1 Like

Yes, chard is self-incompatible (so cross-pollination is mandatory) and wind-pollinated.
An explosive combination! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

But if you and your friends are isolated from any pollen pollution, and you want to participate in their selection, then perhaps we can coordinate! :smiley:

I’m currently looking for partnerships across the EU, but particularly in France, to advance certain projects, whether related to chard or other things.

1 Like

Regarding betalains, removing them is a lost cause.
The best approach is to avoid them altogether from the start.

And wild plants (which ensure perenniality) almost all contain red pigments.
That was the challenge!

Luckily, among wild English chard, I managed to select petioles without betalains, because chard varieties are self-incompatible, so you need to find two similar mutants to stabilize a trait.

White is recessive against all colors; it’s the unicorn of chard! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

So, I wanted to create a perennial chard without color so that, later on, all colors could be created from it!

3 Likes

I’m setting off to PEPS group congress today. Market gardeners from all over France expected gathering around evolutionary populations idea and how to incorporate adaptation gardening concepts. I can spread the word if you want to. I’ll PM you with some of my details for starters and as we converse that can serve as a template for others if they wish to join.

2 Likes

These collaborations are primarily based on a relationship of trust, so I prefer to choose the people I work with! :slightly_smiling_face:

Through my association, I want to create a network that includes:

  • Individuals, acting as β€œContributor Breeders”: they receive batches of seeds for free, and in return, they send me back the hybrids or their seeds.

  • Small-scale professionals, often located near the ArdΓ¨che department (approximately a 2-hour drive), for the vegetative propagation of Alliums in particular.
    They are paid 50% of the selling price and are paid after the sale (harvest in August, sales close in November => 4 months later).

These are the two main types of contracts.
I’m looking for INTERESTED and trustworthy people, with whom I’ve already had some experience! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

2 Likes

New photos !


7 Likes