Modified Kratke system to save the survivors

This year was absolutely brutal for my garden. At the end of the season I had 6 peppers (2 sweet) and 6 tomatoes (out of 40) that had survived without fruiting.

I decided to bring these survivors inside to see if I can get seeds from them.

There is another hydroponics post, but since it was last updated in 2023 I figured I would start my own.

My indoor garden is a modified Kratky system, set up near a sunny south-facing window and with 14 hours of supplemental light. It is self-leveling via hoses that go into a central reservoir.

There are several potted plants as well, including the two sweet peppers.

The Kratke system currently holds 2 cucumbers, 4 hot peppers, and 4 tomatoes, 2 determinate and 2 indeterminate. These plants are not normally considered appropriate for Kratke.

This is where “modified” comes in. In a standard Kratke system each plant stands alone. The nutrients are put in, the plant is put in, and over time the plant drinks down the water, developing specialized air and water roots. By the time the reservoir is empty, the plant, usually greens or some kind of herb, has been harvested. Heavy users like tomatoes will run dry before they have a chance to fruit. If you try to refill the reservoir, the specialized air roots drown and the plant dies.

To solve this problem many people link the system to a reservoir or use float valves to keep the reservoir topped up at a certain level. I chose to use an entirely passive “siphon” system which keeps all the buckets at the same water level. I top up once a day, nutrients and water both go into the central reservoir.

Currently the tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers are fruiting.

I use homemade nutrients. You don’t have to and most people won’t, but I can source my entire system from my property. That’s important to me.

I won’t bore you with the last 15 years of tests and trials and dead plants. The current base is a mix of wood ash and clay, neutralized with vinegar and topped up with water. I use only the liquid portion, currently 1 quart 3 times per week. This provides potassium, calcium, and a number of micronutrients.

A nitrogen source also 3 times per week, and only during bloom and fruiting a weekly 1/4 teaspoon of an aged almond shell ferment for phosphorus.

The nutrients are a work in progress. I think I’ve got the system itself pretty well dialed in.

Using this system I have at least a chance of saving the genetics of plants that survived 2 months of 100+ degree heat, in heavy clay soil, with no supplemental water.

They didn’t produce, but they survived. Others produced a single small fruit and then died. I have kept those seeds as well.

4 Likes

This year was absolutely brutal for my garden. At the end of the season I had 6 peppers (2 sweet) and 6 tomatoes (out of 40) that had survived without fruiting.

I decided to bring these survivors inside to see if I can get seeds from them.

What killed off your plants, I’m wondering? Was it drought?

1 Like

Drought, heavy clay soil, and 2 months of 100+ temperatures with no supplemental water.

2 Likes

oh, I see it in your original post now:

Using this system I have at least a chance of saving the genetics of plants that survived 2 months of 100+ degree heat, in heavy clay soil, with no supplemental water.

Sorry for the redundancy :melting_face:

Hopefully your hydroponic system works and you’re able to get mature seeds - sounds promising!

I’ll have to lurk more and read your other posts to learn more about your farming. I used to garden in heavy clay soil in 7b, but we got 52 inches (1300 mm) of rain in an average year (I was in a subtropical rain forest), which I suspect is a fairly different climate than Kansas.

In terms of ecoregions, it looks like most of Kansas is great plains:

  • 25 Western High Plains
  • 27 Central Great Plains
  • 28 Flint Hills
  • 40 Central Irregular Plains

But in terms of Köppen climate type, most of Kansas is Cfa (Humid Subtropical), which does make it more like the Great Appalachian Valley I am from.

Sounds like there is more rain in the eastern part of Kansas, and the western part is more arid?

When I was dealing with clay soils, I imported a huge amount of organic matter through ChipDrop, and had to use a broad fork to really open up the soil. But I was just gardening on a suburban lot - I guess if I were managing a larger space, I would probably grow cover crops. Fava is supposedly a great cover crop for heavy clay soils because it does such a great job penetrating deep into clay soils.

Anyway, I’m sorry you had such devastating weather this year.

It is very interesting to me that you make your own nutrients - I have heard of this, but never actually read of someone doing it. Do you have a recipe for how much wood ash, clay, vinegar, and water you use? I bet there are others interested in home-made hydroponic nutrients!

1 Like

It’s a work in progress. I started doing the clay-ash mixture this year. I have never measured the clay. I replace the ash about once a week, add 3 Tablespoons and enough vinegar to neutralize it and top off with water in a gallon jug. This suspends the nutrients in solution, in a form the plants can use.

When the clay looks like it’s broken down (I know, pretty subjective) I dump out the jug and start over.

The almond shell ferment is about 8 years old, and a little goes a long way. I use a quarter teaspoon once a week for 6 buckets, 15 gallons of water.

The plants have a nitrogen deficiency at the moment, so looks like I misjudged that.

As for the climate, I’m right on the border between 27 and that lighter pink. Average is 30 inches of rain per year, but since I moved here I think we’ve averaged 15ish.

2 Likes

That’s awesome. The thing I hated when I was working with hydroponics was that it seemed so unsustainable because of the required nutrients and additives.

The nutrients were so expensive (at the time anyway) and the systems were so sensitive and high maintenance. I ended up switching to a separate aquaponics project which I really liked because it was relatively self-sustaining compared to the hydroponics.

1 Like

The clay is the new item. It replaces potassium, iron, copper, nickel, zinc, magnesium and several others I can’t remember at the moment. The vinegar releases the payload from the clay and suspends it in the water.

I do have aquaponics out in the garage. This is just the one I can play with during the winter.

2 Likes

Hi Lanrent,

Your idea seem very cool! Unfortunately the climate is more and more extrem and we must have a safe grow system.

What is the section of your pipe?

What is the power of your lights?

How lany years was requiered for get your recipe on clay and ash and vinegar?