Sourgrass

One thing that grows very well here in NorCal is sourgrass. I was just reading up on it (see quoted material below on uses) and was curious if others eat/use sourgrass regularly (note also the hazards section below)? I know it is invasive here, almost impossible to get rid of, so even as much as I clear, likely to still have more (though also curious if others have successfully gotten rid of it and if so how)?

“Description
The Oxalis pes-caprae flower is actinomorphic, with a calyx composed of five free or slightly fused sepals, a sympetalous corolla composed of five fused petals, an apoandrous androecium composed of ten free stamens in two ranks, and a compound pistil. Native populations in South Africa are heterostylous, flowers of long-styled plants have a stigma held above the two ranks of stamens, mid-styled plants have the stigma inbetween the two ranks of stamens and short-styled plants have a stigma below both ranks of stamen. In the non-native range the plants largely reproduce vegetatively and many populations have only one style length and the plants never produce seed.
Like most African Oxalis species, it produces adventitious subterranean propagules. These take the form of true bulbs in botanical terms, which is unusual among dicotyledons. In fact, Oxalis pes-caprae produces small bulbs copiously, whereas most other African species produce fewer, larger bulbs. New world Oxalis, such as Oxalis corniculata, apparently do not generally produce bulbs.
Invasive species
Indigenous to South Africa, Oxalis pes-caprae, the “Bermuda buttercup”, is an invasive species and noxious weed in many other parts of the world, including the United States (particularly coastal California), Europe, Israel and Australia.
Control
The plant has a reputation for being very difficult to eliminate once it has spread over an area of land. The weed propagates largely through its underground bulbs and this is one reason why it is so difficult to eradicate, as pulling up the stems leaves the bulbs behind. Soil in which the plant has grown is generally contaminated with many small bulbs.
Kluge & Claassens (1990) reported a potential biocontrol agent using Klugeana philoxalis, a larval feeder on shoots of O. pes-caprae.
O. pes-caprae is also a host to broomrape, though it is not clear that that is of significance as a control agent.
Uses
Oxalis pes-caprae is often called by the common name sourgrass or soursop due to its pleasant sour flavor. This sourness is caused by the exceptionally high content of oxalic acid.
The plant is palatable and in modest quantities is reasonably harmless to humans and livestock. In South Africa it is a traditional ingredient in dishes such as waterblommetjiebredie (water flower stew).
The plant has been used in various ways as a source of oxalic acid, as food, and in folk medicine. The raw bulbs have been used to deal with tapeworm and possibly other worms. The plant has been used as a diuretic, possibly hazardously, in the light of observations in the following section. The lateral underground runners, which tend to be fleshy, have been eaten raw or boiled and served with milk. The golden petals can be used to produce a yellow dye.
Hazards
Oxalic acid is toxic in large quantities, a concern in regions such as southern Australia where Oxalis pes-caprae grows invasively in enormous quantities and in high densities. Various sources suggest that oxalis ingestion causes calcium oxalate kidney stones, but clinical experience and physiological considerations as described in the Wikipedia article on kidney stone make it unlikely that any realistic intake of Oxalis would affect human liability to kidney stones. Accordingly, some Australian references to the hazards of oxalis to livestock tend to be dismissive of this risk.
However, in spite of its comparatively benign nature, where it has become dominant in pastures, as sometimes happens outside South Africa, Oxalis pes-caprae certainly can cause dramatic stock losses. For example, when hungry stock, such as sheep released just after being shorn, are let out to graze in a lush growth of Oxalis pes-caprae, they may gorge on the plant, with fatal results, as has been found in South Australia at least.
Such stock fatalities patently have little logical connection with the presence or absence of oxalate kidney stones. For one thing, the fatal effects on sheep are far too rapid to result from the growth of bulk kidney stones. The plant has been found to be nutritious, but too acidic to be good fodder, largely being left untouched by grazing stock. When stock do consume large quantities, the effects typically involve death in several weeks with symptoms suggesting chronic oxalate poisoning, including tetany, or sudden death with extensive renal damage. Such damage suggests the twofold effect of calcium immobilisation (the tetany) and the formation of Calcium Oxalate Monohydrate raphides in the kidney tissue. The histotoxic effects of the raphides in kidney have by now been investigated.
Oxalis poisoning of stock is not a serious forage concern in South African pastures, unless exceptionally favoured by overgrazing.“

1 Like

I don’t know sourgrass as of fifteen minutes ago but am a big fan of using weeds. “Extremely high oxalic acid content” together with the stock fatalities are a little worrisome. The traditional ethnobotanical usage is encouraging. We know oxalic acid content declines with cooking or fermentation - - if all the traditional usages use the plant cooked but it still tastes good raw, that’s definitely a potential data point about its perceived safety when raw.

The fact that the bulbs are traditionally consumed to treat parasites warrants noting as well - - I can’t think of any food on this earth used to treat parasites (I mean actually treat, not support treatment via another method) that is safe to consume immoderately.

Anyway, you probably already knew all that :slightly_smiling_face:

If sourgrass were well-established at our place, I’m guessing I’d explore the traditional usages and more with all the standard caution of new-to-you wild foods.

Oh there’s also this tidbit I found interesting on a patent for lowering oxalic acid in citric acid fermentation. It honestly just sounds like they might be using baking soda to neutralize it. I’m not sure what they traditional equivalents would be but am confident they exist

We didn’t eat it per se, but as kids, the kids in the neighborhood (including me) loved breaking the stems off near the base of the plant and sucking on them. I didn’t realize the were invasive, I’d gladly trade them for many of the invasive weeds I have now, they are so cheery and bright (and tasty, but I guess in small amounts!). Thanks for all the information on it, I assumed it was native.

I somehow missed that this is what we call wood sorrel around here :rofl:.

We eat it raw every year, but in small amounts. Seems like it might be fiddly to harvest enough to do much with (including throwing into a stir fry).

From what I understand there are varieties native to North America. I’m not sure what variety we have here.

I also learned yesterday it seems it’s related to oca. I’ve heard oca can be fiddly to grow, though I think it comes with some compelling advantages over potatoes (edibility and cold tolerance) and even sweet potato. I wonder if crossing with a native oxalis could reduce fiddliness while maintaining some value as a tuber crop?

That sounds like a great idea to me! If you have a wood sorrel that’s a common weed in your area, that may also speak well for oca growing well for you. I would say it’s definitely worth giving a try.